Welcome to our guide on best practices for resume review as a hiring manager. As a hiring manager, reviewing resumes is an essential part of your job to identify the most qualified candidates for open positions at your company. However, with so many resumes to review and limited time available, it can be easy to make mistakes or overlook important details.

In this guide, we will share some best practices and tips to help you effectively review resumes and make the best hiring decisions for your company.

Understand the Job Requirements

Before you even begin reviewing resumes, it's important to have a clear understanding of the job requirements for the position you are hiring for. This will allow you to determine which skills, experiences, and qualifications are necessary for the role and help you narrow down your candidate pool. Take the time to carefully review the job description and make note of any specific requirements or preferences that are listed. This will help you create a clear picture of the ideal candidate for the position.

Create a Structured Review Process

Next, it's important to establish a structured process for reviewing resumes. This will help ensure that you are consistently reviewing and evaluating each resume fairly and objectively. Here are some tips for creating a structured review process:

• Set clear criteria: Determine what specific skills, experiences, and qualifications you are looking for in a candidate and create a list of criteria to evaluate against.

• Use a scoring system: Consider using a scoring system or rubric to help you objectively evaluate each resume. This can be especially helpful when comparing multiple candidates.

• Establish a timeline: Set a deadline for when you will complete resume reviews and stick to it. This will help you stay on track and avoid any delays in the hiring process.

Pay Attention to Formatting and Presentation

In addition to evaluating the content of a resume, it's also important to pay attention to the formatting and presentation. A well-organized and visually appealing resume can give insight into a candidate's attention to detail and communication skills. Look for resumes that are easy to read, with clear headings, consistent formatting, and no spelling or grammatical errors.

Use Keywords to Filter Resumes

Many companies use applicant tracking systems (ATS) to manage the large volume of resumes they receive. These systems often use keywords to filter and rank resumes based on their relevance to a specific job posting. To ensure that your review process is efficient, consider using similar keyword criteria when evaluating resumes. This can help you quickly identify top candidates who possess the necessary skills and experience for the position.

Consider the Whole Package

While a resume is an important piece of the hiring puzzle, it should not be the only factor you consider when making a decision. Take into account other aspects of a candidate's application such as their cover letter, portfolio, and references. These can provide valuable insights into a candidate's personality, work style, and overall fit for the company. Don't be afraid to ask for additional materials or conduct interviews to get a better understanding of a candidate's qualifications and potential.

Provide Constructive Feedback

When reviewing resumes, it's important to provide constructive feedback to candidates, regardless of whether they are selected for the position or not. This can help them improve their resume and overall application for future job opportunities. Be specific in your feedback and highlight areas where the candidate excelled and areas for improvement. This can show that your company values professional development and can leave a positive impression on candidates, even if they weren't chosen for the role.

The Importance of Feedback in Startups

Keep an Open Mind

It's important to approach resume reviews with an open mind, as some top candidates may not have a traditional or "perfect" resume. Look beyond the format and instead focus on the content and relevant experiences a candidate brings to the table. Keep an open mind when evaluating resumes to ensure you don't overlook potential star employees.

Utilize Technology

With advancements in technology, there are now many tools available to assist with resume reviews. Applicant tracking systems (ATS) can help streamline the process by automatically screening resumes for keywords and qualifications. This can save time and help narrow down the pool of potential candidates. Additionally, there are resume review software programs that can provide objective assessments of a candidate's resume, highlighting areas for improvement or red flags to consider. Using technology in conjunction with human review can create a more efficient and effective resume review process.

Stay Consistent

Maintaining consistency in your resume review process can help ensure fairness and accuracy. This includes using the same criteria and guidelines for evaluating all resumes, as well as having multiple reviewers assess each resume to minimize bias. Consistency also means communicating clear expectations to candidates, such as required qualifications or specific skills desired for the role. By staying consistent, you can more accurately compare and evaluate candidates, leading to a stronger hiring decision.

Take Notes

As you review resumes, it can be helpful to take notes on each candidate. This can include highlighting key qualifications or experiences that stand out, as well as any red flags or concerns. These notes can serve as a reference point when discussing candidates with other team members or making further evaluations. They can also help track patterns or trends among applicants, providing valuable insights for future hiring processes.

Consider the Whole Picture

Resume reviews should not solely focus on a candidate's qualifications and experiences listed on their resume. It's important to consider the whole picture - including cover letters, references, and any additional materials submitted by the candidate. While

a resume is an important component of a candidate's application, it should not be the sole factor in your decision-making process. By looking at all aspects of a candidate's application, you can gain a better understanding of their skills, personality, and potential fit for the role.

Be Mindful of Bias

Bias can unknowingly creep into the resume review process, leading to unfair evaluations and decisions. It's important to be mindful of any potential biases you may have as a reviewer and actively work towards eliminating them. This can include using standardized evaluation criteria, having diverse reviewers on your hiring team, and being aware of any implicit biases that may influence your assessments.

In conclusion, effective resume reviews require attention to detail, open-mindedness, and a holistic approach. By taking the time to carefully review and evaluate candidates' resumes, you can make informed decisions that will ultimately benefit your company in the long run.

Remember to keep notes, consider the whole picture, and be mindful of bias - these practices will help streamline your hiring process and lead to successful hires. Good luck!